Is consistency a better measure of excellence?

The best contact centres don’t rely on occasional brilliance. They consistently demonstrate the small, observable behaviours that make good customer conversations work. This article explores why repeatable performance, rather than superstar individuals, may be a better measure of customer experience excellence.

Your best conversation matters less than your most typical one

There’s something interesting about the affection some of the world’s best chefs have for fast food.

People who have dedicated their careers to exceptional food can still get excited about a burger served in a paper wrapper. Gordon Ramsay has said an In-N-Out burger would make his last-meal menu, while Anthony Bourdain, Julia Child and Ina Garten have all been fans of the chain.

And then there’s McDonald’s.

Marco Pierre White once made the provocative argument that McDonald’s could be better than some of London’s top restaurants because of its consistency and value.

Whether you’d go that far isn’t really the point.

What’s remarkable is that millions of people can walk into thousands of McDonald’s restaurants around the world and have a pretty good idea what they’re going to get.

Consistency is part of the product.

And I think there’s something in that for contact centres.

 

What does excellence actually look like?

I’ve spent a lot of years listening to customer conversations. And more recently, listening to conversations submitted for the2026 Auscontact Sales and Service Excellence Awards, something stood out.

The best organisations weren’t relying on flashes of brilliance from individual consultants.

They were consistently doing the little things well.

They asked the right questions. They kept customers informed. They checked understanding. They connected recommendations back to what customers had told them. They made the next step clear.

None of that sounds particularly revolutionary.

In fact, most contact centre leaders would probably look at that list and say, “Of course we do that.”

But do you?

Not occasionally. Not when your best consultant is on the phone. Not in the conversation you choose to play at the next leadership meeting. Consistently.

That’s a very different test.

The 2026 awards reinforced that many of the behaviours distinguishing stronger conversations were quite small. What separated the strongest organisations was how consistently those behaviours showed up.

 

Consistency isn’t sameness

There is an important distinction here.

Consistency doesn't mean tightly scripted conversations where everyone sounds the same.

Two people with completely different personalities can bothseek to understand why something matters to the customer. Both can explain what happens next. Both can check understanding. Both can connect a recommendation to something the customer has said.

They don't need to use the same words to do any of it.

The aim isn't to make every conversation the same. It's tomake the behaviours that create a good conversation consistent.

 

Stop relying on your superstars

Every contact centre has them.

The consultant who seems to instinctively know what to say.The person whose conversations get played in calibrations. The person a team leader can always rely on to demonstrate what “good” sounds like.

There’s nothing wrong with celebrating those people.

The problem is when exceptional performance depends on having exceptional individuals.

Think about the fast-food example again. The strength of the operating model isn’t that, somewhere in the organisation, there is one person capable of producing the world’s greatest burger.

It’s that the desired experience has been broken downsufficiently that it can be reproduced, thousands upon thousands of times.

Customer conversations obviously aren’t hamburgers. They involve judgement, empathy, context and a human being on the other end.

But the principle is worth considering.

If we want great performance to be repeatable, we first need to understand what our best people are actually doing differently.

Not “they’re great communicators” or “they build rapport”. What are the small things they actually do or say that contribute to a better conversation?

This is where I think micro-behaviours matter.

A micro-behaviour takes something broad like “active listening” or “understanding the customer” and turns it into something you can actually see or hear. For example, did the consultant ask a clarifying question before offering advice? Did they paraphrase what they'd heard? Did they check understanding before moving on?

If a particular behaviour improves performance, can we define it? Can we observe it? Can someone practise it? Can a leader coach it?

And, importantly, can we help people repeat it until it becomes part of how they work?

Because you can’t really coach someone to, “be more like Sarah”. You can coach someone to ask a particular question at a particular point in a conversation.

That, for me, is where consistency stops being an aspiration and starts becoming something you can actually build.

The goal isn’t to create more superstars. It’s to understand what your best people do differently and make those behaviours easier for everyone to repeat.

 

Perhaps we’re aiming at the wrong thing

There’s an understandable obsession in customer experiencewith being exceptional.

Exceptional service. Memorable experiences. Moments thatdelight customers.

There’s nothing wrong with that.

But there’s a more fundamental question to answer first:

How good is the experience we deliver most of the time?

One outstanding conversation doesn't compensate for ten mediocre ones. And one brilliant consultant doesn't create a consistently good customer experience if the quality depends entirely on who happens to answer the phone.

That's what I found particularly interesting about this year's Auscontact results.

The strongest organisations weren't necessarily doing extraordinary things. They were doing important things, more consistently.

Maybe that's a better definition of excellence.

Not occasional brilliance. consistently good performance.

Because whether you're serving burgers or talking to customers, the real test isn't how good you can be on your best day.

It's how good you are on an ordinary one.

Your best conversation tells you what's possible.

Your most typical conversation tells you how good your contact centre really is.

 

See what consistency looks like in practice. Explore the 2026 Sales and Service Excellence insights.

Ready to Start Your Pathway?

Ready to move from ideas to results? Pick a quick demo to see workflows, 
or a discovery call to discuss your challenges. We’ll tailor the pathway.